Start with the decision that changes the outcome
Minimum tread depth in the US is a legal baseline, but practical replacement timing often starts sooner when wet traction and braking confidence are already fading.
A legal minimum should not be confused with a best-practice replacement target. Drivers usually benefit from a larger safety margin, especially in rain-heavy conditions.
How to narrow the field quickly
Use tread depth measurements together with wear pattern and weather exposure. That gives the shopper a better answer than the legal number alone.
Best next move
If the tread is near the end of its useful range, move directly into the exact-size comparison page and replace before conditions force the decision.